Welcome to Magpye's Pizzeria
Welcome to Magpye's Pizzeria, the cherished gem of Sterling, Alaska, located at Mile Post 82.7 on the Sterling Highway. Celebrated for its inviting atmosphere and exceptional pizza, this pizzeria creates a unique dining experience that feels like a gathering with friends and family. With murals showcasing local scenery and a menu offering a diverse range of savory options, including fantastic "pizza by the slice," every visit promises quality and value. Guests rave about the warm service and community spirit, making Magpye's a must-visit whether you’re a local or just passing through. Indulge in their acclaimed pies and discover a slice of joy!
Magpye's Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings
"The Cook's Creation." ***Easily the best pizza I have ever had in my entire life. Period.*** My local microbrew was brought to me overflowing from a frozen glass. EPIC. UNIMPROVABLE.
We had a last minute run from Seward/Homer, met in Sterling & they were open. We came in on a sip & paint night. Everyone was collectively shooting the bull. The servers, owner, kitchen staff & customers. It was like being at Thanksgiving with people you like over excellent pizza. 10stars if google had it! We will be back! Angel & Natalie
Friendly server, fun local atmosphere and great pizza. Murals of local scenery and wildlife with a sense of humor cover the walls.
Whether you're passing through or a local to the Peninsula...this is LITERALLY the best pizza on the Kenai. It's worth a stop at the very least, but if you try it once you're going to want to come back. Their "pizza by the slice" is truly the best deal around when it comes to value and quality of pizza...especially if you can't decide on one of the MANY amazing offerings they have. Please don't underestimate how awesome their pizza is. And on top of that, they serve their community in ways they don't ever expect recognition for. We love you Magpye's!
Great food, service and atmosphere! My family loves Magpies!
Awesome food great staff always happy to go back
Pizza was fantastic. Service was excellent. Only downfall was one check for the whole table. But since everything else was great. That was easy to over look. Definitely would eat there again.
We were passing by and it was lunch time and I was in the mood for pizza. We saw restaurant and decided to stop. I’m sure glad we did the pizza was delicious and the crew there were so down to earth and pleasant. If you are driving down south you must stop. The restaurant had large windows with views. I loved it.
Location
-
Mile Post, 82.7 Sterling Hwy, Sterling, AK 99672, United States Hotline: +1 907-262-9397
Welcome to Magpye's Pizzeria, a hidden gem located at Mile Post 82.7 on Sterling Highway in Sterling, Alaska. This delightful pizzeria has carved out a reputation that goes beyond mere pizza; it's a hub for the community. With an inviting atmosphere that combines local charm and warm hospitality, Magpye's is not just a restaurant—it's an experience.
Recently, locals and visitors alike have gathered to enjoy pizzas that are nothing short of extraordinary. As one customer, Michael Bierman, aptly described, it's "the best pizza I have ever had in my entire life." This enthusiasm is echoed by many who rave about the exceptional quality of each dish, highlighting the concoctions from their experienced chefs that are tailored to please any palate.
But the magic of Magpye's goes beyond its culinary offerings. Customers like Angel P-Moe appreciate the vibrant atmosphere, comparing it to a warm Thanksgiving gathering. The essence of community thrives here, where regular patrons and newcomers alike share stories over incredible food. With murals depicting local scenery and humor, the environment is as rich as the flavor of their signature pizzas.
The pizzeria stands out with its remarkable option of "pizza by the slice", perfect for indecisive eaters wanting to sample a variety of the many flavorful offerings. As Jess Beck emphasizes, it's not merely about quality—it's about value. Magpye's has become a staple in Kenai, redefining what a pizzeria can be.
Additionally, the dedicated team at Magpye's is committed to serving the community in unrecognized ways, a quality that resonates deeply with their loyal customers, leading to heartfelt praises like that of Kami Wright, who highlights the consistently great food, service, and atmosphere.
If you find yourself in the Sterling area, stepping into Magpye's Pizzeria is not just a detour; it’s a destination. Whether you're dining with family, grabbing a quick slice, or enjoying a leisurely evening with friends over local brews, Magpye's promises to deliver a slice of happiness on every plate. Come for the pizza, stay for the people, and leave with memories that taste as good as the food.